Dear Author
Just one little note: If you want to write about these topics couldn't you imagine a better main character than an abbess in an 11th-century monastery? After all people who join monasteries usually do this because they want to worship the christian God and not pagan ones (and seriously: I don't think that the 'Aren't all Gods just one higher Being'-POV was very common in the 11th century) and unless you write a story that is set in the early Christian Ireland monks and nuns aren't supposed to marry and have sex, either.
No I'm not talking about fanfic or some 13 year old wannabe-witch, who put her stories on the internet, I'm talking about a published author *sighs*.
I loved the first Alys Clare-book. I'm really into historic novels and crime novels, so historic crime-novels are just perfect for me, but it's quite difficult to find good ones that are set in a historic period I'm interested in. And somehow 'Fortune of the moon' was really promising: set in England during the time of Richard Lionheart (who is after all the grandson of Empress Maud...), and the detective-duo, consisting of an older abbess and a young knight, was unusual and likeable.
I also really enjoyed reading it, not that I'd have called it best book I've ever read, but good enough to read the next one. It wasn't bad. Just strange. In the forest, surrounding the monastery suddenly some forrest-people appeared (well, not suddenly they've been living there for centuries, but they hadn't been mentioned before), who still followed 'the old way'. Somehow the abbess (whose name is Helewise), and the knight Sir Josse observe a ritual of the forest people, when they search the forest for clues in their murder-investigating (BTW: the ritual involves lots of sex), the Domina of the forest people notices them and tells them that the rules tell her to kill them, as they've seen something they shouldn't have seen, but she is going to spare them if they promise not to tell anybody about it. The escape happily, and later Helewise comes to the conclusion that these people aren't that bad after all, and hey -aren't all Gods just one?
The next book (well, chronologically the next after the next, we haven't got all) was even stranger, it involved magic stones, Merlin and plenty of logic-holes, and again an abbess, who again had no problems with ancient heathen magic.
But her view suddenly changed in the next book, but perhaps that was because we didn't have any pagans this time, but evil heretics.
In the next book we learn something new about Helewise, the earlier books already told us, that she didn't join the monastery as young girl, but only after her husband died and that they had two sons. Now we also learn that Helewise had the rare luck to marry a man she actually loved (and who loved her), besides we learn that Helewise and Ivo:
- had sex before they were married (once...on Belthaine)
- had lots of sex when they were married
- had generally great sex
In fact half of the book are Flashbacks of Helewise about her time with Ivo.
Actually I think that the idea of writing books about someone in a monastery who 'has a past' isn't that bad (well, actually Cadfael had a past, too, but it never came out that much), but I really don't need that...
*is now going to read either the new Jasper Fforde, she already got for christmas, the cozy-knitting-mystery or just listen to one of her ???-audio-books, simply anything where she can be sure that it involves neither sex any paganism, something she actually expected from stories set in a monastery*